Selected Book Reviews From Youth Today
(back to book review index)
  Foster Care Horror Story: Same Old Same Old
Foster Care Odyssey: A Black Girl's Story
By Theresa Cameron
University of Mississippi Press
264 pp.; $28; March 2002

By Martha Shirk

Foster care workers who are looking for new insights into the foster care experience won't find them in "Foster Care Odyssey: A Black Girl's Story," the latest memoir about growing up in foster care.

Like the memoirists who have covered this territory before her, notably Dave Pelzer (A Child Called 'It': One Child's Courage to Survive) and Antwone Quenton Fisher (Finding Fish: A Memoir), Cameron describes a childhood that no one would wish on another.

"No Feelings"

Unlike Pelzer and Fisher, Cameron was never beaten or sexually abused. She wasn't starved or locked in a closet. However, that doesn't mean that she was unharmed by her experiences. Abandonment by her birth family and a childhood spent in foster care left Cameron, at least through her nineteenth year, seemingly unable to give or receive love.

Cameron, a 48-year-old associate professor at Arizona State University, has nothing good to say about the human beings who make the foster care system run. "I had no feelings about her, either good or bad," she writes of one caseworker. "This woman was simply one more in a long line of caseworkers, none of whom had ever accomplished what I thought they were supposed to do." As for the several different sets of foster parents with whom she lived, they all made her feel "more like a guest in other people's homes, someone who had overstayed her welcome."

More Insight Required

Cameron's story ends when she goes off to college at age 19. We learn in an epilogue that she earned a bachelor's degree from SUNY-Buffalo, a master's degree from the University of Michigan, and a doctorate from Harvard. Unfortunately, Foster Care Odyssey provides little insight into how she emerged from foster care with the intellectual and emotional tools necessary to reach such academic heights. She attributes her success to two things: "my constant hope that life would eventually change for the better and the unwavering belief that others had in me when I lacked faith in myself." Would that that was all it takes.

The foster care system has changed a lot since the 1950s, '60s, and early '70s, when Cameron was growing up. Changes in federal laws have made it less likely that children will languish for years with little thought given to their long-term futures.

But the system hasn't changed enough to ensure that every foster child has a home in which he is loved - or that he can love in return.


Former St. Louis Post-Dispatch reporter Martha Shirk, a freelance writer in Palo Alto, Calif., is working on a book on what happens to foster children when they age out of the system.
 

(back to book review index)

(back to navigation screen)

(back to top)